White Stripes>Jack White

[Randy]

Konkretno me interesuje sta mislite o Jack White-u.On je po meni strava lik.Ono ima strava gitare,jedinstven stil tj. razlikuje se od ostalih.I ako znate neke bendove koje slicne White stripes-u napisite.

[Duane]

i ja mislim da ima strava gitare

[nemanjavelimirovic]

Meni je on taman kako treba muzicar, sve shto svira je taman. A shto se tice gitara...pa uzeo bih mu verovatno bar 80 posto gitara

[Dersu Uzala]

Hmmm, let's see sta kaze publika...

"This whole band sounds like two drunk teenagers got together and jammed in their garage. If this is the direction American music is leading - I will leave the country. There is no excuse for this garbage!"

"90% of the public has the ability to make this music. There is nothing new here. No profound lyrics, not catchy melody, no musicianship. This is one of the worst bands I have ever heard."

"Cmon, are you people kidding? The future of Rock n Roll, The Great White Hope? Well, if this is the future of rock n roll then for sure rock is DEAD!!! This stuff is unoriginal, uninteresting, and should be thrown in the burning slag heap along with The Strokes and most certainly The Vines. Neo-rock?? Huh?? This shit is pure hype by the people at V2 records. The only interesting thing about this group is the video with the animated legos, a fitting video for them, because they themselves are plastic!! There is nothing new here people. Is music so bad we are lead to believe that this is good? Somebody besides me must know this. This is music for trendy scenesters who dont know JACK SQUAT!!! You want this type of stuff, by Raw Power!! What is this even supposed to be? First boy bands and now rock music has de-evolved to this piece of detritus. Dont be a sucker, take this band's records and burn 'em, and repeat after me "We're through being cool!" and then go out and by something you really like, not what they tell you to like. Think for yourself."

"Jack White cannot play guitar. He cannot sing. The drum lines are played similar to a child who has just learned 'rock beat one'. There is no bass whatsoever. However, these facts could be overlooked if the actual music showed some originality. It does not. Four chord riffs, rock beat one, shaky vocal lines - Jack White has no songwriting talent whatsoever. I have no problem if you like this band, but they are NOT, by any stretch of the imagination, the brilliant band that so many people think they are. As a musician, I actually find this kind of stuff offensive to listen to. "

"These people need to go home and PRACTICE - prac·tice (pr kts) v. prac·ticed, prac·tic·ing, prac·tic·es Repeated performance of an activity in order to learn or perfect a skill: Practice will make you a good musician. Practice might not help The White Stripes at all.
A session of preparation or performance undertaken to acquire or polish a skill: goes to piano practice weekly; scheduled a soccer practice for Saturday. Middle English practisen , from Old French practiser , alteration of practiquer , from practique ,practice , from Medieval Latin practica . See practicable ."


"Lemme just say, Jack and Meg, color coordinating doesn't make you interesting OR inventive, nor does it distract me from the derivative music that you make. You are NOT the saviors of rock n' roll!
In fact, Jack sounds like he's trying to channel Robert Plant, and let's face it boys and girls, Led Zeppelin are perhaps as tasteless as Phil Collins or Huey Lewis and the News!
To be fair, I won't deny that Jack and Meg are good musicians, but that's certainly no guarantee for respectability. I don't like ANY of their songs; Jack's voice is shrill and whiny and annoying; his guitar work is more show-offish than anything; none of his songs have a particularly interesting hook; his lyrics are good examples of why dumb people should avoid attempting poetry (that includes you, too, Jewel), and again, this whole fashion thing isn't clever. It's a gimick, just like their "music". I've read that The White Stripes are even called a blues band. What??? They're from Michigan!!!
Frankly, I'd rather punish myself with a marathon of Dr. Phil than mess with this junk.
For those of you that disagree, listen to the Immortal Lee County Killers--now *that's* a good two-piece rock n' roll band.
And they're from Alabama, so they have a true testament to the ideology of the blues. "

"Why the hell does everyone like these posers anyway. If you want to hear music by musicans that can't play their instruments, than check out pussy galore instead. But If you want real blues rock checkout the black keys. P.S. Jack white can go screw himself. Anyone who disses Stevie Ray Vaughn (Jack White, prim.prev) should burn in hell."


"TWS serve up rehashed basic chords and basic, boring grade-school drumming that are supposed to somehow make them seem original, hip, and supposedly forging a 'new direction'. All this band offers is a third-rate mishmash of directionless, already done a million times garage band talentless noise by a duo of dorky mediocre musicians with bad fashion sense, who insist on dressing in candy cane colors as part of their schtick. Maybe if they entered the music scene in the late 70's/early 80's 'post punk' era, they would have been appreciated more. Bottom line... life is short... don't waste your time!"


"I see a reviewer here compared the guitar work to Rush. This is somewhat misleading, for the following reason: whereas the guitar work in Rush is superb and frequently astounding, the guitar work in White Stripes is absolutely awful, periodically ascending to lousy. So you see the two are not quite as similar as the other reviewer would have you believe.

To get down to brass tacks, here's the deal with this recording. This is one of those times where there's a band that everyone has decided is cool, so you, wanting to be hip, purchase their recording. Having had a few listens, you struggle to find some redeeming quality in the music; unfortunately, the stuff is junk. You struggle to suppress the truth and make overblown comments about the "return to rock", the "gritty rawness" of it all, and so forth. Your buds all make the same sort of crummy, sanctimonious observations, none of you realizing that each secretly knows that it's all lies and the music is no good.

Years later you dig it up in a box in your basement and have a good laugh at yourself. Kind of a kick, I guess, but wouldn't you rather keep the cash? "


"This music is nothing more than another lousy untalented release of some stupid overnight 4 chord modern-day garage band that the young pimply 'trendoids' have latched onto in order to look hip and 'with the times'! Fact is, the musicianship and songs are lacking in a big way, and these clowns sound like rank amateurs, if that. They are a band that proves that most young music fans have very low standards as to what they expect from musicians these days, in comparison to older folks, who grew up in a time when rock bands were arguably better and more talented! This band's CD would make a good expensive coaster. "


"All you bad taste trendies thinking you are jumping onto something new and cool are obviously musically stunted bigtime! If this music is your idea of good back-to-basics rock, then you need to find another band to listen to. This band is the WORST i've EVER heard, with boring, 3-chord guitar tunes, and the worst vocalist i've ever heard over my 3 decades of listening to rock music! Sonically, the instruments sound compressed and flat, and the recordings are the worst i've ever heard. Seriously.
If you have any taste in music and recording quality, do yourself a favor and skip over this dissapointment! "

[nemanjavelimirovic]

Hehehehe, zabavno je citati to... Najlakse je popljuvati neshto shto ne kontash... pogotovo shto su to verovatno rivjui iz nekog hevi mjetal magazina
Meni je recimo pokazatelj to da im ljudi ipak i pored svega napisanog veoma u velikom broju dolaze na koncerte (znam shta sledi dalje od komentara - pa ljudi dolaze i na Cecin koncert i na Bregin...itd, ali ne treba zanemariti da je ovo vrlo iskrivljena muzika, tj nije cak ni klasicni rok ili bluz, vec neshto drugacije)

Jbg, ne solira lik brzo, ali shta cesh, neko mora i sporije i da pravi disharmoniju i mikrofoniju (moj covJek)...
Jos jedna tema koja obecava Mortal Combat! Jeee! Me like it!
Jedan od onih bendova gde bih mogao sve instrumente odsvirati isto ko i oni, ali treba to i izmisliti u tome je caka...meni su vrh kao i Black Keys.

[Dersu Uzala]

Svi citati su sa Amazon.com.

[whosyourdaddy]

Dersu (ser-du) skini te kozne pantalonice, iskljuci mesu, i pusti si neki stari blues.

[Jack Nape]

Rock n roll je po meni od nastanka i bio muzika koja je bila zameisljena da moze da je svira nekoliko klinaca sa idejom, bez ikakvog muzickog skolovanja. Postoje svakako ljudi koji su taj izraz doveli skoro da savrsenstva i svaka cast, ali insistirati iskljucivo na tome je besmisleno. To je kao i sa slikarima ima onih koji naslikaju nesto identicno kao fotografija i ima onih koji naslikaju nesto sto moze i trogodisnje dete pa im slika vredi hiljade dolara. Onaj prvi komentar sa amazona, cini mi se, i ako koncipiran kao pljuvacina zapravo i jeste sustina onoga kako je ovaj pravac muzike nastao, s toga mislim da je jack, kao i njegovi bendovi sjajan. Naravno da me neko pogresno ne razume ogromno postovanje imam i prema onima koji to rade na drugi nacin (zna se na sta mislim).

[Jack Nape]

Postoji muzika gde pojam: "pijani tinejdzeri koji sviraju u garazi" ne prolazi nikako i nikako se ne uklapa, ali to je klasicna muzika ne rok.

[Dersu Uzala]

Dersu (ser-du) skini te kozne pantalonice, iskljuci mesu, i pusti si neki stari blues.

Sto ja batice, citati nisu moji nego od kupaca njihovih ploca sa Amazona?!? Ja ne kupih nijednu pa nisam ni komentarisao. You don't wanna hear my notes, trust me. Sva sreca izmislili Ameri internet, pa eto i tebe da cujemo.

[nenadnenad]

dersu seres ko i svaki drugi balkanac sa foruma posredno ili neposredno...

[Duane]

šonešone nešto nisi raspoložen lately?

[nemirkv]

Odlican je Jack, cak i bubnjeve zasvir'o

[Dersu Uzala]

Ovo je muzika, za ove neobavestene:

[MetalFunk]

Ne, to je tvoja interpretacija "sta je muzika". Mr. Obavesteni.